Publisher: Tokyopop (books), Viz (digital)
Volumes: 5/5 (Complete), (Books- OOP but not hard to find, Digital- Available)
Seinen
Genre: Supernatural, Fighting, Ecchi
Summary: A virus is raging the planet and it turns infected people into monsters, called Kamiyadori. Jillead and Vivi are partners as so-called Right Arms of the Sculdra, an organization that kills the infected who have “erupted” or changed. In this cruel world, a medicine exists to prevent the infected from erupting, called Suppress, but it has become expensive as they cannot make enough of it to meet demand. This has led to a widening gap between the rich and poor as the Sculdra frantically try to contain the virus and prevent more infections.
Review: So this is rank 5 because this story is so broken, I can’t imagine anyone actually wanting to read this. The main issue is that the story reads like an exercise in world building, and has some decent character introduction flashbacks towards the end, but there’s no actual story. Each volume raises more questions about the characters and the world, and introduces a ridiculous number of new characters, as there are basically no answers at all. Not even hints.
It’s kind of a shame because there is some interesting stuff in here. For example there is a prison for the infected called the Temple of Isolation, which no one has ever returned from alive. We know they watch for outbreaks and kill any who erupt, but we don’t even know if they are supplied with Suppress or treated humanely or not. Similarly, there’s a fake Suppress street drug that only delays the monster transformation, which the Sculdra are hunting down the drug dealers. But again this arc has zero resolution as they kill a drug dealer, the ones who got deprived of it erupt immediately, and they’re all killed. There’s zero followup and no one questions whether this is a good idea or not. If nothing else you’d think it would be smarter to trace all the buyers before killing the dealers…
There’s also plenty of questions around the main two characters. Vivi, in particular, is a feral child who can barely speak, urinates in the street and digs through trash, but somehow possesses amazing fighting abilities. She also bears resemblance to the girl who was the mysterious origin of the virus, who was also a feral child who didn’t speak. But again, no answers. And Jillead, who is a symbiotic carrier of the virus, can use boosted Kamiyadori abilities without turning into a monster, but this is barely explored at all. There's also a small arc about him refusing to use his right hand and special abilities as he accidentally killed his infected sister with it. But all that happens is he loses his resolve and never finds it again.
Anyway, literally this entire series is nothing but questions. There aren’t even any hints to go on that someone might be able to guess what the author was going for. And then the ending is absolutely terrible, as the author wraps up the series in an extremely rushed way, with two of the characters speculating on the fate of the world. They insist that somehow humanity will win, even though as far as the story was telling us, humanity is losing terribly. There is a sequel in Japan but that was never licensed or even scanlated,
It's really hard to believe that somehow this manga and Testarotho are both from the same mangaka as the popular series Erased, but yeah... I double checked...
Not Recommended: I can’t imagine who would want to read this broken story that has zero resolution and no answers whatsoever to any of the plots that start but never resolve. Similarly, none of the character arcs go anywhere and there is no ending either. Go read Erased instead.
Age Rating: Older Teen: quite a decent amount of monster transformation related gore and killings, and a bunch of young women including Vivi who inexplicably fight half naked or sometimes completely naked sometimes.
Other works in English from this mangaka (from most to least popular): Erased, Robot (1 story in an Anthology), Testarotho
Showing posts with label (Publisher) Tokyopop. Show all posts
Showing posts with label (Publisher) Tokyopop. Show all posts
Thursday, July 16, 2020
Monday, July 13, 2020
Million Tears (rank 3)
Publisher: Tokyopop (Books- OOP but not hard to find), Viz (Digital- Available)
Volumes: 2/2 (Complete)
Shoujo
Genre: Supernatural, Romance, Fantasy
Summary: Hiromu goes looking for one of his classmates, only to find out no one knows who he’s talking about, including the other club members, his teacher, and even his girlfriend. He soon meets a strange guy who calls him “Glorious Lily” and says his name is Vermillion. He tells him that both of them aren’t even human- they’re immortal beings known as Destiny Thieves, and they eat human souls and their existence, erasing the fact they ever existed.
He also tells him that Glorious' real love is another Destiny Thief named Valeriana, a beautiful woman who has been sitting in a chair, unresponsive like a doll, for a long time. As “Hiromu” starts to remember his past life, he becomes increasingly uneasy with living forever at the expense of humans. Can he make peace with his life as a Destiny Thief and immortality? And will Valeriana ever wake up?
Review: Overall, this was a very good, solid story, and also my favorite one from this mangaka. It’s touching and thoughtful, and the romance was sweet and tragic. This story also kind of feels like a Vampire story, as major themes in the story also center around the loneliness of immortality and the guilt of taking lives to continue your own. Only in some ways the Destiny Thieves are even worse than Vampires, because they don’t just kill- they erase everything a person ever did by eating them. Finally it ends fine, but has an unexpectedly happy ending which could have used more explanation. But it was alright.
Recommended: If you want to read a tragic supernatural romance that has an unexpectedly happy ending, then this was a good read.
Age Rating: PG
Other works from this Mangaka in English: (from most to least popular): Haru Hana, Flower of a Deep Sleep, The Mermaid Prince
Volumes: 2/2 (Complete)
Shoujo
Genre: Supernatural, Romance, Fantasy
Summary: Hiromu goes looking for one of his classmates, only to find out no one knows who he’s talking about, including the other club members, his teacher, and even his girlfriend. He soon meets a strange guy who calls him “Glorious Lily” and says his name is Vermillion. He tells him that both of them aren’t even human- they’re immortal beings known as Destiny Thieves, and they eat human souls and their existence, erasing the fact they ever existed.
He also tells him that Glorious' real love is another Destiny Thief named Valeriana, a beautiful woman who has been sitting in a chair, unresponsive like a doll, for a long time. As “Hiromu” starts to remember his past life, he becomes increasingly uneasy with living forever at the expense of humans. Can he make peace with his life as a Destiny Thief and immortality? And will Valeriana ever wake up?
Review: Overall, this was a very good, solid story, and also my favorite one from this mangaka. It’s touching and thoughtful, and the romance was sweet and tragic. This story also kind of feels like a Vampire story, as major themes in the story also center around the loneliness of immortality and the guilt of taking lives to continue your own. Only in some ways the Destiny Thieves are even worse than Vampires, because they don’t just kill- they erase everything a person ever did by eating them. Finally it ends fine, but has an unexpectedly happy ending which could have used more explanation. But it was alright.
Recommended: If you want to read a tragic supernatural romance that has an unexpectedly happy ending, then this was a good read.
Age Rating: PG
Other works from this Mangaka in English: (from most to least popular): Haru Hana, Flower of a Deep Sleep, The Mermaid Prince
Saturday, July 11, 2020
Flower of a Deep Sleep (rank 3.5)
Publisher: Tokyopop (books- OOP but not hard to find), Viz (digital- available)
Volumes: 2/2 (Complete)
Shoujo
Genre: Fantasy, Supernatural, Romance
Summary: Yuuki doesn’t have it easy. She has the special ability to see premonitions of the future in her dreams, but no matter how hard she’s tried, she’s never been able to stop her bad visions from happening. And for some reason she needs to pick her future husband from the arranged marriage choice of two boys before she’s 20. These two boys also have special abilities- Ryuune, who has the power to see inside people’s hearts, and Ryuunosuke who can take away people’s pain.
Together all three of them need to solve the mystery of why those who Yuuki dreams of getting led away by a little girl, soon fall into a deep coma- including Yuuki’s sister, who was the first victim! Can she finally change the future she saw? And which boy will she choose to be her future husband?
Review: This series and other works by this mangaka used to be moderately popular for the art style and their sort of fantasy, dream-like atmosphere. But as time has gone by they have gotten more and more obscure, as the competition in Shoujo manga has gotten much more intense.
All in all this story is decently good. If you’re willing to accept the conceits of the story and not ask too many questions, then it’s a short bittersweet story about the hidden pain in people’s hearts. The sort of sadness that nearly everyone carries with them, but most people learn how to deal with it, and accept it as part of life. The best part of this story is the ending, which also has a theme of sisterly love.
But if you can’t accept the story as it is, then it feels very melodramatic and exaggerated as nothing really all that terrible happens in this story, but the main characters act like their worlds are falling apart.
Recommended: If you enjoy the artwork and want to read a slightly mysterious story about the hidden pain in people’s hearts, then you might enjoy this. If that sounds cheesy to you, then don’t bother with it.
Age Rating: PG for some bullying and very mild violence.
Other works in English from this Mangaka (from most to least popular): Haru Hana, Million Tears, Mermaid Prince
Volumes: 2/2 (Complete)
Shoujo
Genre: Fantasy, Supernatural, Romance
Summary: Yuuki doesn’t have it easy. She has the special ability to see premonitions of the future in her dreams, but no matter how hard she’s tried, she’s never been able to stop her bad visions from happening. And for some reason she needs to pick her future husband from the arranged marriage choice of two boys before she’s 20. These two boys also have special abilities- Ryuune, who has the power to see inside people’s hearts, and Ryuunosuke who can take away people’s pain.
Together all three of them need to solve the mystery of why those who Yuuki dreams of getting led away by a little girl, soon fall into a deep coma- including Yuuki’s sister, who was the first victim! Can she finally change the future she saw? And which boy will she choose to be her future husband?
Review: This series and other works by this mangaka used to be moderately popular for the art style and their sort of fantasy, dream-like atmosphere. But as time has gone by they have gotten more and more obscure, as the competition in Shoujo manga has gotten much more intense.
All in all this story is decently good. If you’re willing to accept the conceits of the story and not ask too many questions, then it’s a short bittersweet story about the hidden pain in people’s hearts. The sort of sadness that nearly everyone carries with them, but most people learn how to deal with it, and accept it as part of life. The best part of this story is the ending, which also has a theme of sisterly love.
But if you can’t accept the story as it is, then it feels very melodramatic and exaggerated as nothing really all that terrible happens in this story, but the main characters act like their worlds are falling apart.
Recommended: If you enjoy the artwork and want to read a slightly mysterious story about the hidden pain in people’s hearts, then you might enjoy this. If that sounds cheesy to you, then don’t bother with it.
Age Rating: PG for some bullying and very mild violence.
Other works in English from this Mangaka (from most to least popular): Haru Hana, Million Tears, Mermaid Prince
Monday, July 6, 2020
Brave Story (rank 3.5)
Publisher: Tokyopop
Volumes: 5/20 (Cancelled), OOP but not hard to find
Shounen (reads like)
Genre: Fighting, Fantasy, Isekai
Summary: Wataru is having a tough time. He is only good at one thing- videogames- and the new transfer student Ashikawa is wowing everyone with his good looks, top grades and athletics. Meanwhile Wataru’s parents are getting divorced and the girl he has a crush on, Kaori, likes Ashikawa instead. But he finds out Ashikawa’s secret- he has magical abilities and can open a portal into another world, called Vision. There players from our world fight each other over orbs. Getting 5 Orbs unlocks your full fighting abilities and opens the door to the Tower of the Goddess, who will grant one wish to the first person who defeats the Trials of the Tower.
After Wataru’s mother attempts to commit suicide, he resolves to put his family back together with the wish. Kaori also enters and becomes a player as well, and also has her own wish she wants granted. Can they survive the dangerous other world? Can they manage the resolve to defeat other players?
Review: This manga feels kind of generic, even though the story had potential. The way the manga goes, (mild spoilers, highlight to read) Ashikawa quickly surpasses Wataru and joins the villains side, but remains a sort of friend/rival to Wataru. Kaori pretty quickly gets kidnapped and taken by the bad guys and becomes a host to an evil spirit and supposedly has some destiny to fulfill. Lastly Wataru manages to beat a couple of enemies with his special ability- the Brave Blade, which is powered by heart/willpower. It’s a super powerful ability but has a very short time limit.
This manga made some strange decisions. Ashikawa has a more interesting motivation and back story, as well as being very intelligent, to the point where it seems like he’s the real main character. And I had thought Wataru’s talent at video games would be more important to the plot, but it soon becomes clear that it’s more about his pure heart and willpower and is never mentioned again.
This manga was adapted from a Light Novel, also called Brave Story. The Novel has overall higher review ratings than the manga, and while the manga was cancelled with 15 more volumes left to go, the Novel is complete in one gigantic 800 page Omnibus out from Viz. So basically if you want the whole complete story, read the Novel instead.
It also seems like the manga is much weaker overall between the two. Reviews say that in particular Wataru’s character was changed to be more a generic, slacker videogamer as opposed to the more thoughtful and sympathetic Novel version. Also that the plot loses the epic feel and the more memorable emotional growth that he has in the Novel.
Not Recommended: TLDR; This manga is really very average. Most readers will probably want to check out the Novel instead, since it’s got better reviews and tells a complete story, and the manga was cancelled anyway.
Age Rating: PG13: some mild gore, moderate violence, and some mild brief female nudity.
Other Novels from the author: (from most to least popular): ICO: Castle in the Mist, The Book of Heroes
Volumes: 5/20 (Cancelled), OOP but not hard to find
Shounen (reads like)
Genre: Fighting, Fantasy, Isekai
Summary: Wataru is having a tough time. He is only good at one thing- videogames- and the new transfer student Ashikawa is wowing everyone with his good looks, top grades and athletics. Meanwhile Wataru’s parents are getting divorced and the girl he has a crush on, Kaori, likes Ashikawa instead. But he finds out Ashikawa’s secret- he has magical abilities and can open a portal into another world, called Vision. There players from our world fight each other over orbs. Getting 5 Orbs unlocks your full fighting abilities and opens the door to the Tower of the Goddess, who will grant one wish to the first person who defeats the Trials of the Tower.
After Wataru’s mother attempts to commit suicide, he resolves to put his family back together with the wish. Kaori also enters and becomes a player as well, and also has her own wish she wants granted. Can they survive the dangerous other world? Can they manage the resolve to defeat other players?
Review: This manga feels kind of generic, even though the story had potential. The way the manga goes, (mild spoilers, highlight to read) Ashikawa quickly surpasses Wataru and joins the villains side, but remains a sort of friend/rival to Wataru. Kaori pretty quickly gets kidnapped and taken by the bad guys and becomes a host to an evil spirit and supposedly has some destiny to fulfill. Lastly Wataru manages to beat a couple of enemies with his special ability- the Brave Blade, which is powered by heart/willpower. It’s a super powerful ability but has a very short time limit.
This manga made some strange decisions. Ashikawa has a more interesting motivation and back story, as well as being very intelligent, to the point where it seems like he’s the real main character. And I had thought Wataru’s talent at video games would be more important to the plot, but it soon becomes clear that it’s more about his pure heart and willpower and is never mentioned again.
This manga was adapted from a Light Novel, also called Brave Story. The Novel has overall higher review ratings than the manga, and while the manga was cancelled with 15 more volumes left to go, the Novel is complete in one gigantic 800 page Omnibus out from Viz. So basically if you want the whole complete story, read the Novel instead.
It also seems like the manga is much weaker overall between the two. Reviews say that in particular Wataru’s character was changed to be more a generic, slacker videogamer as opposed to the more thoughtful and sympathetic Novel version. Also that the plot loses the epic feel and the more memorable emotional growth that he has in the Novel.
Not Recommended: TLDR; This manga is really very average. Most readers will probably want to check out the Novel instead, since it’s got better reviews and tells a complete story, and the manga was cancelled anyway.
Age Rating: PG13: some mild gore, moderate violence, and some mild brief female nudity.
Other Novels from the author: (from most to least popular): ICO: Castle in the Mist, The Book of Heroes
Wednesday, June 24, 2020
Phantom Dream (rank 3.5)
Publisher: Tokyopop
Volumes: 5/5 (Complete), OOP but not hard to find
Shoujo
Genre: Romance, Exorcists, Reincarnation
Note: the plot unfolds with many deliberate twists, but honestly, it’s also kind of a confusing, disjointed messy read. So there are two summaries, one summary for volume 1 to spoil nothing, and one for the overall series that contains mild spoilers to help new readers make sense of the story.
Summary: (Volume 1) Tamaki is the reluctant heir to a line of Exorcists. In this world, those who are consumed with negative emotions, Jashin, turn into Jaki, a sort of demon that can kill others with a thought. An incomplete Jaki can be turned human again, but a full Jaki can only be killed. He tries to learn how to master his abilities while he faces his first two Jaki, Mitsuru-chan, an old childhood friend of his and Asahi’s (his girlfriend), and Souichi, a bullied and sick boy who loves butterflies. In the end, the Gekka reveal themselves- those who have been turning people into Jaki. But for what end?
Mild Spoiler filled summary (highlight to read)
One thousand years ago, there lived a special woman, Suigekka, who could use spiritual magic. She had two brothers by her side, Hira and Saga who both loved her. After her death they both sought to carry on what they perceived as her will and their children split into two family lines. One family became a corrupting influence, that uses Black Magic to get revenge for Suigekka, and the other family became a line of purifying Exorcists that defends humans from Black Magic.
A number of those drawn by a sort of fate gather together: Tamaki, the curent Exorcist heir, the branch families that support the Exorcist with supportive spells, and the Gekka, their enemies. Asahi, Tamaki’s girlfriend, has a secret connection to the two families. And finally, Hira who has managed to use magic to stay alive for a thousand years. All to gather in a final conflict to finally put an end to the story that started so long ago.
Review: The story isn’t bad, but this is Natsuki Takaya’s debut work (of Fruits Basket fame), and it really shows. The beginning is kind of confusing and the story is a bit bogged down by leaving all the Exorcist related terms untranslated. It’s sort of rough and disjointed. That whole plot summary (the second one) is pieced together by a lot of flashbacks and dramatic reveals.
But if you’re willing to slog through the messy story, with a large cast, it is moderately rewarding. Without spoilers, I would say it’s a story about Love, Tragedy, Revenge and then finally Redemption.
I would say the part that really stayed with me was the ending, it was new and refreshing from what I expected, from what is at heart, a story about revenge. I also really appreciated the added epilogue that details what happened to all the other characters after the end of the story, it was a nice touch.
Recommended: This one will probably be of most interest to Fruits Basket fans, if they want to see how her style evolved. As a story on it’s own merits, it’s got it’s moments but overall felt really rough. But it’s somewhat rewarding to read as well.
Age Rating: PG for some violence and deaths.
Other Works by this mangaka (from most to least popular): Fruits Basket, Fruits Basket Another, Twinkle Stars, Liselotte & Witch's Forest, Tsubasa: Those With Wings. Songs to Make you Smile
Volumes: 5/5 (Complete), OOP but not hard to find
Shoujo
Genre: Romance, Exorcists, Reincarnation
Note: the plot unfolds with many deliberate twists, but honestly, it’s also kind of a confusing, disjointed messy read. So there are two summaries, one summary for volume 1 to spoil nothing, and one for the overall series that contains mild spoilers to help new readers make sense of the story.
Summary: (Volume 1) Tamaki is the reluctant heir to a line of Exorcists. In this world, those who are consumed with negative emotions, Jashin, turn into Jaki, a sort of demon that can kill others with a thought. An incomplete Jaki can be turned human again, but a full Jaki can only be killed. He tries to learn how to master his abilities while he faces his first two Jaki, Mitsuru-chan, an old childhood friend of his and Asahi’s (his girlfriend), and Souichi, a bullied and sick boy who loves butterflies. In the end, the Gekka reveal themselves- those who have been turning people into Jaki. But for what end?
Mild Spoiler filled summary (highlight to read)
One thousand years ago, there lived a special woman, Suigekka, who could use spiritual magic. She had two brothers by her side, Hira and Saga who both loved her. After her death they both sought to carry on what they perceived as her will and their children split into two family lines. One family became a corrupting influence, that uses Black Magic to get revenge for Suigekka, and the other family became a line of purifying Exorcists that defends humans from Black Magic.
A number of those drawn by a sort of fate gather together: Tamaki, the curent Exorcist heir, the branch families that support the Exorcist with supportive spells, and the Gekka, their enemies. Asahi, Tamaki’s girlfriend, has a secret connection to the two families. And finally, Hira who has managed to use magic to stay alive for a thousand years. All to gather in a final conflict to finally put an end to the story that started so long ago.
Review: The story isn’t bad, but this is Natsuki Takaya’s debut work (of Fruits Basket fame), and it really shows. The beginning is kind of confusing and the story is a bit bogged down by leaving all the Exorcist related terms untranslated. It’s sort of rough and disjointed. That whole plot summary (the second one) is pieced together by a lot of flashbacks and dramatic reveals.
But if you’re willing to slog through the messy story, with a large cast, it is moderately rewarding. Without spoilers, I would say it’s a story about Love, Tragedy, Revenge and then finally Redemption.
I would say the part that really stayed with me was the ending, it was new and refreshing from what I expected, from what is at heart, a story about revenge. I also really appreciated the added epilogue that details what happened to all the other characters after the end of the story, it was a nice touch.
Recommended: This one will probably be of most interest to Fruits Basket fans, if they want to see how her style evolved. As a story on it’s own merits, it’s got it’s moments but overall felt really rough. But it’s somewhat rewarding to read as well.
Age Rating: PG for some violence and deaths.
Other Works by this mangaka (from most to least popular): Fruits Basket, Fruits Basket Another, Twinkle Stars, Liselotte & Witch's Forest, Tsubasa: Those With Wings. Songs to Make you Smile
Friday, June 12, 2020
Erica Sakurazawa: Between the Sheets (rank 3)
Publisher: Tokyopop
Volumes: 1/1 (Complete) OOP but not hard to find
Yuri/Josei
Genre: Romance
Summary: One day while at a bar, Saki kisses her best friend, Minako, to get some guys to leave them alone by pretending they’re a lesbian couple. Minako falls head over heels for Saki and soon starts to obsess over her. She even sleeps with Saki’s boyfriend because she wants to know what it’s like to be Saki. Saki tries to turn her down but Minako doesn’t give up, she keeps trying to break up Saki with her boyfriend. Meanwhile, Saki cheats on her boyfriend as well.
Review: Man this is a difficult read about the obsessive, self destructive love Minako has for Saki. On the upside, it’s an intense story that made me wonder where it was going. On the downside, they’re all kind of awful people who cheat on each other. The ending is pretty dark as well, but it does fit with the themes of the story.
Recommended: If you want to read a twisted romance, if you want to read a wholesome romance, this really isn’t it.
Age Rating Older Teen: This has a bunch of short consensual sex scenes in it.
Age Rating Older Teen: This has a bunch of short consensual sex scenes in it.
Erica Sakurazawa: Angel Nest (rank 3)
Publisher: Tokyopop
Volumes 1/1 (Complete), OOP but not hard to find
Josei
Genre: Friendship, Romance (extra side stories)
Summary: One day Natsu comes home early only to discover her husband Ken is cheating on her with a former student of his, Emi. But she doesn’t care, their relationship had been loveless for quite some time. One night she sees an Angel and it starts hanging around the apartment. The next day Emi shows up, she broke up with Ken but he’s been stalking her. She asks if she can stay with Natsu “because this is the last place Ken will look”. Natsu agrees and they start to strike up an odd friendship.
The main story Angel Nest is only about half of the volume, the rest is three additional short stories:
God Only Knows: Haru and his gay friend Tobio are hanging out in a bar when they meet Sakiko, who doesn’t look like she belongs there. Later Haru goes outside to get some air and saves Sakiko from getting raped. Somehow they all decide to go to the beach and end up talking about life.
Tea Time: A slightly older woman who starts out her island vacation alone has a passionate fling with a younger guy while she knows her boyfriend is also cheating on her too. This one has a consensual sex scene.
A Gift from the Heavens: A guy steals a Mercedes that was left running for a joyride, but then discovers a woman in the backseat. They spark an instant mutual attraction.
Review: The main story-line, Angel Nest was actually pretty interesting. It was unexpected that they both dump Ken and become friends, but it works. And the older woman, Natsu, ends up becoming sort of a mother figure/mentor to Emi. It’s a sweet story.
The short stories on the other hand, didn’t interest me much at all. God Only Knows, didn’t really seem to have a point to the story. Tea Time has that whole “I’m cheating on you but it’s OK because you cheated on me too” thing again. And then Gift from the Heavens, the whole setup of getting involved with a complete stranger who happens to be in the car the main character stole, was too weird for me.
Recommended: I would recommend the main story as a story about an unusual friendship. But somehow for Josei, the only passionate romance type story is the extra story Tea Time.
Age Rating: Older Teen just for the short Tea Time
Other Works from this mangaka: (from most to least popular):
Volumes 1/1 (Complete), OOP but not hard to find
Josei
Genre: Friendship, Romance (extra side stories)
Summary: One day Natsu comes home early only to discover her husband Ken is cheating on her with a former student of his, Emi. But she doesn’t care, their relationship had been loveless for quite some time. One night she sees an Angel and it starts hanging around the apartment. The next day Emi shows up, she broke up with Ken but he’s been stalking her. She asks if she can stay with Natsu “because this is the last place Ken will look”. Natsu agrees and they start to strike up an odd friendship.
The main story Angel Nest is only about half of the volume, the rest is three additional short stories:
God Only Knows: Haru and his gay friend Tobio are hanging out in a bar when they meet Sakiko, who doesn’t look like she belongs there. Later Haru goes outside to get some air and saves Sakiko from getting raped. Somehow they all decide to go to the beach and end up talking about life.
Tea Time: A slightly older woman who starts out her island vacation alone has a passionate fling with a younger guy while she knows her boyfriend is also cheating on her too. This one has a consensual sex scene.
A Gift from the Heavens: A guy steals a Mercedes that was left running for a joyride, but then discovers a woman in the backseat. They spark an instant mutual attraction.
Review: The main story-line, Angel Nest was actually pretty interesting. It was unexpected that they both dump Ken and become friends, but it works. And the older woman, Natsu, ends up becoming sort of a mother figure/mentor to Emi. It’s a sweet story.
The short stories on the other hand, didn’t interest me much at all. God Only Knows, didn’t really seem to have a point to the story. Tea Time has that whole “I’m cheating on you but it’s OK because you cheated on me too” thing again. And then Gift from the Heavens, the whole setup of getting involved with a complete stranger who happens to be in the car the main character stole, was too weird for me.
Recommended: I would recommend the main story as a story about an unusual friendship. But somehow for Josei, the only passionate romance type story is the extra story Tea Time.
Age Rating: Older Teen just for the short Tea Time
Other Works from this mangaka: (from most to least popular):
- Nothing But Loving You (Shoujo/Josei)
- Between the Sheets (Yuri/Josei)
- Angel (Josei)
- Rules of Love (Josei)
- Aromatic Bitters (Josei)
Erica Sakurazawa: Angel (rank 4)
Publisher: Tokyopop
Volumes 1/1 (Complete), OOP but not hard to find
Shoujo/Josei
Genre: Slice of Life, Romance
Summary: It’s a short story collection about an Angel that never speaks, but shows herself to people in need of help and improves their lives. This includes: a lonely single guy at a bar, a bullied high school girl, and a neglected little girl who's single mother drinks too much.
Review: It’s three somewhat connected short stories where the main characters in each all briefly bump into each other, but otherwise have no connection other than the Angel. As short stories go, they are sweet stories that end happily, but honestly I felt they were kind of bland. It feels like they go on a little too long before they get to the point. I also would have rather each story had been separate from the others instead of this overlapping type narrative.
Recommended: For Josei, only one of these stories (the single guy at the bar) was Romance. The other two are normal stories. All in all they were fine, but nothing really special.
Not Recommended: Even compared to Erica Sakurazawa’s other works in English, I feel like this was one of the weakest.
Other Notes: Angel Nest is technically a sequel to this, but they have nothing in common except the Angel.
Age Rating PG13: Alcoholism, bullying and suicide attempt, and some making out.
Other Works from this mangaka: (from most to least popular):
Volumes 1/1 (Complete), OOP but not hard to find
Shoujo/Josei
Genre: Slice of Life, Romance
Summary: It’s a short story collection about an Angel that never speaks, but shows herself to people in need of help and improves their lives. This includes: a lonely single guy at a bar, a bullied high school girl, and a neglected little girl who's single mother drinks too much.
Review: It’s three somewhat connected short stories where the main characters in each all briefly bump into each other, but otherwise have no connection other than the Angel. As short stories go, they are sweet stories that end happily, but honestly I felt they were kind of bland. It feels like they go on a little too long before they get to the point. I also would have rather each story had been separate from the others instead of this overlapping type narrative.
Recommended: For Josei, only one of these stories (the single guy at the bar) was Romance. The other two are normal stories. All in all they were fine, but nothing really special.
Not Recommended: Even compared to Erica Sakurazawa’s other works in English, I feel like this was one of the weakest.
Other Notes: Angel Nest is technically a sequel to this, but they have nothing in common except the Angel.
Age Rating PG13: Alcoholism, bullying and suicide attempt, and some making out.
Other Works from this mangaka: (from most to least popular):
- Nothing But Loving You (Shoujo/Josei)
- Between the Sheets (Yuri/Josei)
- Angel Nest (Josei)
- Rules of Love (Josei)
- Aromatic Bitters (Josei)
Erica Sakurazawa: The Rules of Love (rank 3.5)
Publisher: Tokyopop
Volumes 1/1 (Complete), OOP but not hard to find
Josei
Genre: Romance
Summary: Taku is a total player who has a bunch of girls on speed dial. He doesn’t have a job and constantly borrows money from the women he sleeps with. One day he gets kicked out of his apartment over not paying rent and an incident with one of his lovers. He meets Chizu, a young woman who’s never been in love. Chizu falls heads over heels for him and lets him move in the next day. This is the story of their bittersweet summer of love.
Review: According to the narration and the back cover this is supposed to be a bittersweet romance story about a short, passionate love. But honestly I felt like it's more accurate to say it was about a naive girl who gets her heart broken by a guy who cared about her a little bit more than his other flings but not enough to actually completely change his ways. It wasn't a bad story, but more bitter than sweet to be sure.
Recommended: For Josei, it’s alright, but it’s basically a story about a heartbreak. Compared to the other Erica Sakurazawa works, I’d say this is nothing particularly special.
Age Rating: Older Teen: this story has consensual sex in it.
Other Works from this mangaka: (from most to least popular):
Review: According to the narration and the back cover this is supposed to be a bittersweet romance story about a short, passionate love. But honestly I felt like it's more accurate to say it was about a naive girl who gets her heart broken by a guy who cared about her a little bit more than his other flings but not enough to actually completely change his ways. It wasn't a bad story, but more bitter than sweet to be sure.
Recommended: For Josei, it’s alright, but it’s basically a story about a heartbreak. Compared to the other Erica Sakurazawa works, I’d say this is nothing particularly special.
Age Rating: Older Teen: this story has consensual sex in it.
- Nothing But Loving You (Shoujo/Josei)
- Between the Sheets (Yuri/Josei)
- Angel Nest (Josei)
- Angel (Josei)
- Aromatic Bitters (Josei)
Erica Sakurazawa: The Aromatic Bitters (rank 3.5)
Publisher: Tokyopop
Volumes: 1/2 (Dropped), OOP but not hard to find
Josei
Genre: Romance
Summary: Sayumi (31) and Hide (40) (pronounced Hee-Day btw) are best friends and are both stuck in loveless relationships with their significant others that they can’t quite seem to leave. One day on a vacation Sayumi meets a younger guy, Yusuke, who she falls in love with. Unsure of what to do, she goes to talk to Hiroyuki, her boyfriend, only to find him cheating on her. She moves out to live with Yusuke. Meanwhile, Hide’s husband asks for a divorce and is cheating on her too. She then also meets a younger guy and sparks of love fly.
Review: If there’s one trope I don’t like in these Erica Sakurazawa stories, it’s the whole “well I cheated on you, but you were cheating on me too, so it cancels out”. Anyway, it’s not a bad story, but it seems to strangely endorse Older Women and Younger Men relationships as if it’s a solution to loveless relationships or something.
Unfortunately this series had a second volume that was never released in English. So there’s no ending, but at the same time the story was like ⅔ of the way done and you can kind of guess how it might have ended. It mostly stands on its own.
Recommended: It’s alright. If you don’t like stories where adults act like teenagers, then yeah. Also there is so much cheating as well.
Age Rating: Older Teen
Other Works from this mangaka (from most to least popular):
Volumes: 1/2 (Dropped), OOP but not hard to find
Josei
Genre: Romance
Summary: Sayumi (31) and Hide (40) (pronounced Hee-Day btw) are best friends and are both stuck in loveless relationships with their significant others that they can’t quite seem to leave. One day on a vacation Sayumi meets a younger guy, Yusuke, who she falls in love with. Unsure of what to do, she goes to talk to Hiroyuki, her boyfriend, only to find him cheating on her. She moves out to live with Yusuke. Meanwhile, Hide’s husband asks for a divorce and is cheating on her too. She then also meets a younger guy and sparks of love fly.
Review: If there’s one trope I don’t like in these Erica Sakurazawa stories, it’s the whole “well I cheated on you, but you were cheating on me too, so it cancels out”. Anyway, it’s not a bad story, but it seems to strangely endorse Older Women and Younger Men relationships as if it’s a solution to loveless relationships or something.
Unfortunately this series had a second volume that was never released in English. So there’s no ending, but at the same time the story was like ⅔ of the way done and you can kind of guess how it might have ended. It mostly stands on its own.
Recommended: It’s alright. If you don’t like stories where adults act like teenagers, then yeah. Also there is so much cheating as well.
Age Rating: Older Teen
Other Works from this mangaka (from most to least popular):
- Nothing But Loving You (Shoujo/Josei)
- Between the Sheets (Yuri/Josei)
- Angel Nest (Josei)
- Angel (Josei)
- Rules of Love (Josei)
Saturday, June 6, 2020
.hack//4Koma (rank 4)
Publisher: Tokyopop
Volumes: 1 (Complete), OOP but not hard to find
Shounen
Genre: Video games, 4koma. Comedy
Summary: This volume is about half 4koma about the .hack characters: mostly .hack//GU+ but for reasons that are beyond me, Kite and Balmung and some others are in it too. There’s also some short 1-2 page each short manga called Gaspard’s Go Go The World about a newbie’s adventures. Lastly there is a short story in a regular manga format called Peaco’s Story about Haseo and Atoli.
Review: I have only read the .hack manga that was put out by Tokyopop and I haven’t played any of the games or watched any of the anime past the first one. So honestly while I found this manga decently entertaining, I also didn’t entirely get what was going on the whole time. I got the .hack//GU+ jokes, which make up about half of the content of this book, but a lot of the rest of it flew over my head.
All in all it was still enjoyable, but nothing really exceptional. I can definitely say someone who’s never had any experience with the .hack lore would be totally lost reading this though. But for 4Koma they were pretty good.
Gaspard’s Go Go The World was alright. I liked the art style fine but none of the 1-2 page stories were all that entertaining. Kind of unfortunate, I mean newbie adventures sounded like it could have been interesting.
Lastly Peaco’s Story was sweet. If you ship Haseo and Atoli I think you will enjoy it.
Recommendations: At the very minimum I think you would need to have read .hack//GU+ to get some of the jokes. I imagine it would be even better if you’ve played some of the games, (I haven’t at all) but even then I still don’t entirely get why Kite acts so crazy.
Not recommended: If you have no experience with .hack at all, don’t pick this one up first. At the very least I would start with .hack//Legend of the Twilight’s Bracelet manga (which explains the setting and the game) and .hack//GU+ manga (like half the 4koma and the short story are about .hack//GU+ characters)
Age Rating: PG: for some very mild violence
Volumes: 1 (Complete), OOP but not hard to find
Shounen
Genre: Video games, 4koma. Comedy
Summary: This volume is about half 4koma about the .hack characters: mostly .hack//GU+ but for reasons that are beyond me, Kite and Balmung and some others are in it too. There’s also some short 1-2 page each short manga called Gaspard’s Go Go The World about a newbie’s adventures. Lastly there is a short story in a regular manga format called Peaco’s Story about Haseo and Atoli.
Review: I have only read the .hack manga that was put out by Tokyopop and I haven’t played any of the games or watched any of the anime past the first one. So honestly while I found this manga decently entertaining, I also didn’t entirely get what was going on the whole time. I got the .hack//GU+ jokes, which make up about half of the content of this book, but a lot of the rest of it flew over my head.
All in all it was still enjoyable, but nothing really exceptional. I can definitely say someone who’s never had any experience with the .hack lore would be totally lost reading this though. But for 4Koma they were pretty good.
Gaspard’s Go Go The World was alright. I liked the art style fine but none of the 1-2 page stories were all that entertaining. Kind of unfortunate, I mean newbie adventures sounded like it could have been interesting.
Lastly Peaco’s Story was sweet. If you ship Haseo and Atoli I think you will enjoy it.
Recommendations: At the very minimum I think you would need to have read .hack//GU+ to get some of the jokes. I imagine it would be even better if you’ve played some of the games, (I haven’t at all) but even then I still don’t entirely get why Kite acts so crazy.
Not recommended: If you have no experience with .hack at all, don’t pick this one up first. At the very least I would start with .hack//Legend of the Twilight’s Bracelet manga (which explains the setting and the game) and .hack//GU+ manga (like half the 4koma and the short story are about .hack//GU+ characters)
Age Rating: PG: for some very mild violence
Missing: Kamikakushi no Monogatari (rank 3)
Publisher: Tokyopop
Volumes: 3/3 (Complete), OOP but not hard to find
Shounen (reads like)
Supernatural, Ghost Stories
Summary: A gloomy, cynical teen nicknamed “the Lord of Darkness” by his friends in the literature club has always been obsessed with ghost stories. In particular, the Kamikakushi legends of people spirited away by spirits, never to return.
One day he meets a mysterious girl that no one else can see. She warns him if he stays with her, he will be unable to return to his world forever. But he refuses to leave, and instead introduces her to his friends at school, seeming to have some plan in mind. Shortly after, he vanishes and his friends set out to find him and bring him back.
Review: On the good parts of this series, I thought the world building was top notch. It was really interesting to create this explanation where spirits, ghosts, and other legends in our world are actually these formless, shapeless creatures from another dimension that have been at war with humans since the dawn of time. They take the shapes of things in human stories to find those who can see them, and steal them away for some unknown purpose. There's even more to it, if that interested you.
On the downside, I gotta say these set of characters were so generic. It’s honestly kind of hard to tell the Literature Club members apart by personality, because they all act kinda similar and bland. I have read this twice and I can barely remember any of the characters other than the secret agent guy and the girl who likes the “Lord of Darkness”.
Recommended: So if you want to read a sort of meta ghost story that explains all other ghost stories, you might enjoy this. If you’re looking for something more romantic, or spooky, then I don’t know. There’s like a touch of horror and a little bit of romance, but it is really mostly all about the ghost stories.
Other notes: This manga was based on a 15 volume Light Novel series also called Missing that was cancelled, and was also from Tokyopop. The first few light novel volumes are available used. One of these days I’ll check it out and see if it was better than the manga.
Age Rating: PG13 for some mild horror and mild violence
Volumes: 3/3 (Complete), OOP but not hard to find
Shounen (reads like)
Supernatural, Ghost Stories
Summary: A gloomy, cynical teen nicknamed “the Lord of Darkness” by his friends in the literature club has always been obsessed with ghost stories. In particular, the Kamikakushi legends of people spirited away by spirits, never to return.
One day he meets a mysterious girl that no one else can see. She warns him if he stays with her, he will be unable to return to his world forever. But he refuses to leave, and instead introduces her to his friends at school, seeming to have some plan in mind. Shortly after, he vanishes and his friends set out to find him and bring him back.
Review: On the good parts of this series, I thought the world building was top notch. It was really interesting to create this explanation where spirits, ghosts, and other legends in our world are actually these formless, shapeless creatures from another dimension that have been at war with humans since the dawn of time. They take the shapes of things in human stories to find those who can see them, and steal them away for some unknown purpose. There's even more to it, if that interested you.
On the downside, I gotta say these set of characters were so generic. It’s honestly kind of hard to tell the Literature Club members apart by personality, because they all act kinda similar and bland. I have read this twice and I can barely remember any of the characters other than the secret agent guy and the girl who likes the “Lord of Darkness”.
Recommended: So if you want to read a sort of meta ghost story that explains all other ghost stories, you might enjoy this. If you’re looking for something more romantic, or spooky, then I don’t know. There’s like a touch of horror and a little bit of romance, but it is really mostly all about the ghost stories.
Other notes: This manga was based on a 15 volume Light Novel series also called Missing that was cancelled, and was also from Tokyopop. The first few light novel volumes are available used. One of these days I’ll check it out and see if it was better than the manga.
Age Rating: PG13 for some mild horror and mild violence
.hack//GU+ (rank 4)
Publisher: Tokyopop
Volumes: 5/5 (Complete), OOP but not hard to find
Shounen
Genre: Fighting, Videogames, MMORPG
Summary: Haseo is a famous player in an virtual reality game, as a Player Killer who only kills other Player Killers (PKK) known as “The Terror of Death”. His goal is to go after a PK named Tri-Edge, who has somehow put his friend Shino into a coma after he PK’ed her. While trying to rescue her and solve the other mysteries of “The World”, Haseo gets involved with a group known as .hack//GU looking for answers.
Review: This manga was interesting. I did read all the way to the end, but I found it a mix of some very interesting ideas, some sympathetic characters, but also a very rough artwork and story. Like seriously, sometimes the art was absolutely gorgeous, but other times looked sketchy and unfinished, lots of closeups to the point where it’s hard to tell what’s going on, and just sort of a rushed look overall. But when the artwork is polished, it was nice.
The story is interesting. Back before Sword Art Online existed, there was .hack, involving stories about being trapped in virtual reality games and MMORPGs affecting the real world. That being said, for all its flaws, Sword Art Online is the better story, even though the .hack franchise was the first in the now sub genre.
After reading a massive amount of .hack lore, there’s this interesting subplot about a Westworld style world, where a secret researcher in AI and other advancements was funded and sold his research as a MMORPG game engine. But underneath it all lies a new form of intelligent life and has created a game that evolves on its own without the help of programmers.
And yet at the same time there are a lot of Scifi elements that seem outright impossible to exist and the mechanisms and reasons for their existence is never explained.
That being said, even though I find the concepts behind the story interesting, the actual story here is somewhat rushed, messy and leaves a lot unexplained. There’s also a weird pacing thing, where at this manga’s pace it really only should have had one final boss. Instead they defeat the boss by volume 3, there’s like an intermission, and then the last volume features a second boss. It was a really rushed fight, a proper length for this series ought to have been at least 7 volumes.
All in all, I still enjoyed it, but it’s hard to imagine non-.hack savvy readers enjoying this. That being said, at least it’s an actual complete story, unlike .hack//Link.
Recommended: for fans of the .hack franchise. If you are not a fan, I would start with .hack//Legend of the Twilight’s Bracelet manga. That one assumes you know nothing about the game, so it’s a better introduction for new readers.
Rating: PG13: some moderate violence
Volumes: 5/5 (Complete), OOP but not hard to find
Shounen
Genre: Fighting, Videogames, MMORPG
Summary: Haseo is a famous player in an virtual reality game, as a Player Killer who only kills other Player Killers (PKK) known as “The Terror of Death”. His goal is to go after a PK named Tri-Edge, who has somehow put his friend Shino into a coma after he PK’ed her. While trying to rescue her and solve the other mysteries of “The World”, Haseo gets involved with a group known as .hack//GU looking for answers.
Review: This manga was interesting. I did read all the way to the end, but I found it a mix of some very interesting ideas, some sympathetic characters, but also a very rough artwork and story. Like seriously, sometimes the art was absolutely gorgeous, but other times looked sketchy and unfinished, lots of closeups to the point where it’s hard to tell what’s going on, and just sort of a rushed look overall. But when the artwork is polished, it was nice.
The story is interesting. Back before Sword Art Online existed, there was .hack, involving stories about being trapped in virtual reality games and MMORPGs affecting the real world. That being said, for all its flaws, Sword Art Online is the better story, even though the .hack franchise was the first in the now sub genre.
After reading a massive amount of .hack lore, there’s this interesting subplot about a Westworld style world, where a secret researcher in AI and other advancements was funded and sold his research as a MMORPG game engine. But underneath it all lies a new form of intelligent life and has created a game that evolves on its own without the help of programmers.
And yet at the same time there are a lot of Scifi elements that seem outright impossible to exist and the mechanisms and reasons for their existence is never explained.
That being said, even though I find the concepts behind the story interesting, the actual story here is somewhat rushed, messy and leaves a lot unexplained. There’s also a weird pacing thing, where at this manga’s pace it really only should have had one final boss. Instead they defeat the boss by volume 3, there’s like an intermission, and then the last volume features a second boss. It was a really rushed fight, a proper length for this series ought to have been at least 7 volumes.
All in all, I still enjoyed it, but it’s hard to imagine non-.hack savvy readers enjoying this. That being said, at least it’s an actual complete story, unlike .hack//Link.
Recommended: for fans of the .hack franchise. If you are not a fan, I would start with .hack//Legend of the Twilight’s Bracelet manga. That one assumes you know nothing about the game, so it’s a better introduction for new readers.
Rating: PG13: some moderate violence
.hack//Link (rank 4)
Publisher: Tokyopop
Volumes: 3/3 (Cancelled in Japan), OOP, vol 3 is hard to find but not too hard if you're patient
Shounen
Genre: Inside a Video Game, Fighting, MMORPGs
Summary: (from Tokyopop) Tokio Kuryu is an avid gamer who misses his chance to play the new release of the hugely popular online game, The World. His problems are seemingly solved when a mysterious transfer student offers him a black-labeled copy only to be suddenly transported into a game where the legendary hero Kite is battling a brand new evil organization! Now it’s up to Tokio to figure out what’s going on in The World and set it right!
Review: I don’t think I’ve ever roller coasted from excited about a manga series to disappointed so quickly. When I started reading it, it seemed like a solid Shounen title set in the .hack world, like it was going to be a kind of standard- but enjoyable- save the day, beat the bad guys, get the girl sort of story. Unfortunately the series was cancelled.
The Good part: this manga doesn’t require a lot of knowledge of .hack, since everything and everyone is mostly introduced and it stands mostly on it’s own. It does help if you’ve read .hack//GU+ manga or played the games but it’s not necessary. That being said, the quality of the panel layouts and the artwork are much better than .hack//GU+.
The Bad part: Well, the series was cancelled in Japan and they didn’t even give the story time to wrap up, not even a rushed ending. So it just ends on a cliffhanger. Apparently sales of both the game and the manga were so poor, that the creator said on twitter it’s likely it will never be finished.
The series had promise, it could have been way better than it was with some tweaks here and there. But as it is, nothing is explained, like:
Recommended: Die-hard completionist .hack fans only.
Other comments: really blatant pantyshots that feel weird in an otherwise for-kids sort of manga. Also there is a weirdly stereotyped German player who is cringey, to say the least.
Review: I don’t think I’ve ever roller coasted from excited about a manga series to disappointed so quickly. When I started reading it, it seemed like a solid Shounen title set in the .hack world, like it was going to be a kind of standard- but enjoyable- save the day, beat the bad guys, get the girl sort of story. Unfortunately the series was cancelled.
The Good part: this manga doesn’t require a lot of knowledge of .hack, since everything and everyone is mostly introduced and it stands mostly on it’s own. It does help if you’ve read .hack//GU+ manga or played the games but it’s not necessary. That being said, the quality of the panel layouts and the artwork are much better than .hack//GU+.
The Bad part: Well, the series was cancelled in Japan and they didn’t even give the story time to wrap up, not even a rushed ending. So it just ends on a cliffhanger. Apparently sales of both the game and the manga were so poor, that the creator said on twitter it’s likely it will never be finished.
The series had promise, it could have been way better than it was with some tweaks here and there. But as it is, nothing is explained, like:
- How did Tokio get transported inside the game by the black disc?
- What’s Saika’s goal, and why does she look like the princess in his dreams?
- Why are the cores and Akashic Records so important?
- What is Schicksal’s goal and why? Why don’t the game admins stop them?
Recommended: Die-hard completionist .hack fans only.
Other comments: really blatant pantyshots that feel weird in an otherwise for-kids sort of manga. Also there is a weirdly stereotyped German player who is cringey, to say the least.
.hack//Alcor (rank 4)
Publisher: Tokyopop
Volumes: 1/1 (Complete), OOP but not hard to find
Shoujo (reads like)
Genre: Video games, Friendship
Summary: Nanase hates herself. She leaves her old game guild and joins a new one where both her crush, guild leader Silabus, and the famous Duel Arena queen Alkaid are in, in hopes of changing herself. But how can she change when her past won’t leave her alone?
Other notes: This is a side character’s story in the .hack world.
Review: Based on the cute Shoujo style and the Tokyopop summary involving her crush, Silabus, I had thought this was going to be a romance story where she wins over his love. What it actually is, is a story about friendship and trying to figure out what defines you. The central friendship in the story is actually between her and Alkaid.
Apparently to fully understand the background of where this story fits in the .hack universe, you need to have played .hack//GU (the game). But aside from the fact I thought it was weird that they didn’t explain anything about The World for a stand alone single volume manga, at least the friendship part of the story doesn’t require any explanation. If you know basic MMORPG stuff I think it’s not too hard to follow the basic story-line.
The Tokyopop age rating on this is Teen, but honestly it feels more like a kid’s manga. The art is very cute and Nanase is painfully clueless and lacks basic social skills that elementary school kids have. It also really seemed hard to imagine that was she was originally in a PK guild, and that they got so annoyed at her leaving they harassed her afterwards. She is more like a sort of quiet girl who doesn’t draw much attention to herself in the real world scenes, so it really didn’t make much sense.
That being said, the ending was sweet, even if a lot of things don’t make a lot of sense. If you don’t dwell on it, it’s a decent story about friendship.
Recommended: I think this would be more enjoyable to Shoujo readers who don’t mind a sweet friendship story, but since it requires at least a little .hack knowledge to follow the basic plot, that probably isn’t a very large pool of potential readers. And as far as .hack fans are concerned, I doubt they would be very interested in a story about a minor side character who isn’t very important or very interesting, really.
So all in all... most people can really safely skip this one.
Age Rating: PG
Other notes: This is a side character’s story in the .hack world.
Review: Based on the cute Shoujo style and the Tokyopop summary involving her crush, Silabus, I had thought this was going to be a romance story where she wins over his love. What it actually is, is a story about friendship and trying to figure out what defines you. The central friendship in the story is actually between her and Alkaid.
Apparently to fully understand the background of where this story fits in the .hack universe, you need to have played .hack//GU (the game). But aside from the fact I thought it was weird that they didn’t explain anything about The World for a stand alone single volume manga, at least the friendship part of the story doesn’t require any explanation. If you know basic MMORPG stuff I think it’s not too hard to follow the basic story-line.
The Tokyopop age rating on this is Teen, but honestly it feels more like a kid’s manga. The art is very cute and Nanase is painfully clueless and lacks basic social skills that elementary school kids have. It also really seemed hard to imagine that was she was originally in a PK guild, and that they got so annoyed at her leaving they harassed her afterwards. She is more like a sort of quiet girl who doesn’t draw much attention to herself in the real world scenes, so it really didn’t make much sense.
That being said, the ending was sweet, even if a lot of things don’t make a lot of sense. If you don’t dwell on it, it’s a decent story about friendship.
Recommended: I think this would be more enjoyable to Shoujo readers who don’t mind a sweet friendship story, but since it requires at least a little .hack knowledge to follow the basic plot, that probably isn’t a very large pool of potential readers. And as far as .hack fans are concerned, I doubt they would be very interested in a story about a minor side character who isn’t very important or very interesting, really.
So all in all... most people can really safely skip this one.
Age Rating: PG
Friday, June 5, 2020
The Other Side of the Mirror (rank 3) (manhua)
Publisher: Tokyopop
Volumes: 2/2 (Complete), OOP, but not hard to find
Seinen (reads like) actually Josei
Romance
Summary: Two down on their luck people meet one day in New York City and spark a romance: Lou, who makes a living by betting he can out drink other guys in bar bets, and Sunny, a prostitute who was abandoned by her boyfriend at a gas station and left to fend for herself. Despite their differences, they feel an attraction to each other and quickly get involved. Will it be enough to turn their lives around?
Review: This series fills me with such conflict. The cover art really attracted me, but at the same time I felt repelled by how emotionless and empty inside they looked. And the title, “The Other Side of the Mirror” was cool, and I had hoped perhaps it was a story about identity or something similar.
Instead, it’s a romance, but honestly... it’s so unromantic. The two of them are so jaded, cynical, burnt out and slightly traumatized by their pasts. The world beats them down and they struggle so much, it is really hard to read, it’s quite depressing. Their worlds seem so hopeless with no chance of escape. They both gave up on their dreams and even the smallest happiness seems beyond their grasp.
Somehow, amazingly it manages to end happily, which was nice to see. Not saying every romance needs to end happily, but it would have been super frustrating to see them start and end still in their super shitty lives.
Other notes: surprisingly, this is a manhua set in New York City (well, volume 1 anyway) and not an OEL, and it reads right to left. The actual main story is really quite short, only 1.5 volumes. The rest of it is 3 unrelated short stories.
Mini Short Stories review: Overall I liked the short stories better than the main story. The best short was “Funeral Procession of the Stars”, a ghost story. It’s way too short to summarize without spoiling anything, so I won’t.
The second best, IMO, was “Peggy” but even though I enjoyed it, it was basically a big tease for BL readers. BL fans will probably find the story to be pretty cruel- it’s the sort of story that offers hope, only to throw it all away.
Lastly, “99 Roses” which was stupid. The first half seems like a fantasy romance, and then the twist ending... was really lame. I don’t see the point of a story that looks set up to be a fantasy romance and then be like... haha fooled you! It’s not romantic at all! It's kind of dumb.
Recommended: All in all, I think Jo Chen is definitely a creator to watch out for, I think she has some serious talent in both writing and art, but somehow I feel like she hasn’t quite managed to make her masterpiece(s) yet.
Volumes: 2/2 (Complete), OOP, but not hard to find
Seinen (reads like) actually Josei
Romance
Summary: Two down on their luck people meet one day in New York City and spark a romance: Lou, who makes a living by betting he can out drink other guys in bar bets, and Sunny, a prostitute who was abandoned by her boyfriend at a gas station and left to fend for herself. Despite their differences, they feel an attraction to each other and quickly get involved. Will it be enough to turn their lives around?
Review: This series fills me with such conflict. The cover art really attracted me, but at the same time I felt repelled by how emotionless and empty inside they looked. And the title, “The Other Side of the Mirror” was cool, and I had hoped perhaps it was a story about identity or something similar.
Instead, it’s a romance, but honestly... it’s so unromantic. The two of them are so jaded, cynical, burnt out and slightly traumatized by their pasts. The world beats them down and they struggle so much, it is really hard to read, it’s quite depressing. Their worlds seem so hopeless with no chance of escape. They both gave up on their dreams and even the smallest happiness seems beyond their grasp.
Somehow, amazingly it manages to end happily, which was nice to see. Not saying every romance needs to end happily, but it would have been super frustrating to see them start and end still in their super shitty lives.
Other notes: surprisingly, this is a manhua set in New York City (well, volume 1 anyway) and not an OEL, and it reads right to left. The actual main story is really quite short, only 1.5 volumes. The rest of it is 3 unrelated short stories.
Mini Short Stories review: Overall I liked the short stories better than the main story. The best short was “Funeral Procession of the Stars”, a ghost story. It’s way too short to summarize without spoiling anything, so I won’t.
The second best, IMO, was “Peggy” but even though I enjoyed it, it was basically a big tease for BL readers. BL fans will probably find the story to be pretty cruel- it’s the sort of story that offers hope, only to throw it all away.
Lastly, “99 Roses” which was stupid. The first half seems like a fantasy romance, and then the twist ending... was really lame. I don’t see the point of a story that looks set up to be a fantasy romance and then be like... haha fooled you! It’s not romantic at all! It's kind of dumb.
Recommended: All in all, I think Jo Chen is definitely a creator to watch out for, I think she has some serious talent in both writing and art, but somehow I feel like she hasn’t quite managed to make her masterpiece(s) yet.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
Support this Site at RightstufAnime.com
I'm happy to announce I'm now a Rightstuf affliate! If you find my reviews helpful and would like to support this site, then please ...
-
Publisher: Kodansha Volumes: 5/5 (Complete), (Digital only, so far) Shoujo Genre: Romance, Twins, (Relationship) Sisters Summary : Mahiru Ya...
-
I know it's been a long time since my last update. Even though I was getting a good amount of traffic for a new blog on the days that I ...
-
Publisher: Kodansha Volumes: 21/21 (Complete) (Digital Only) Shounen Genre: Life and Death Games, Survival Horror, Supernatural, Ecchi, Hare...
























